Skip to content

Homes For Sale In Randall Manor

Randall Manor

Randall Manor is located on Staten Island’s North Shore, and it offers the best aspects of a New York suburb, while still having easy access to all of life’s necessities. Known best for its lush, tree-lined streets and old-world charm, you’ll also have an easy time commuting in and around the larger, busier parts of Staten Island. Looking for a beautiful home on Staten Island? Randall Manor might be for you.

Randall Manor Real Estate Statistics

Average Price $858K
Lowest Price $649K
Highest Price $1.1M
Total Listings 5
Avg. Days on Market 42
Avg. Price/SQFT $527

Property Types
(active listings)

Homes For Sale In Randall Manor

Sort by:

About Randall Manor

Randall Manor is one of the more distinguished neighborhoods on Staten Island‘s North Shore. Named for Captain Robert Richard Randall, the founder of nearby Sailors Snug Harbor, this area is between New Brighton and West Brighton. Its geographical bounds are marked by Bard Avenue to the West, Henderson Avenue to the North, Forest Avenue to the South, and Lafayette Avenue to the East – this encompasses a region that was once known as Elliottville.

Unlike other affluent neighborhoods on Staten Island that are positioned along the island’s central hills, Randall Manor is much more flat. Its development was largely completed before the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge was opened in 1964, shielding it from the subsequent construction boom. The historical stability contributes to Randall Manor’s reputation as one of the most desirable and attractive places to live on the island, maintaining its charm, but still quite close to the St. George Ferry terminal.

Randall Manor Homes For Sale

The real estate in Randall Manor reflects its status as a more upscale neighborhood, with a variety of homes ranging from well-preserved mid-century residents to the occasional more modern home. The neighborhood is characterized by its mature trees and more often than not, beautifully maintained gardens. The architectural styles vary, providing an array of choices for new residents, from classic colonials to charming Cape Cods.

Homeowners in Randall Manor benefit from the neighborhood’s stability and aesthetic appeal, which ensure that property values remain high. The area’s proximity to key Staten Island attractions and daily essentials make it a top choice for those looking to invest in New York City real estate. Most homes are close to or just above $1M in value, with a few more affordable options also available. Whether for families looking for more space and comfort, or professionals wanting a bit more peace in their lives, Randall Manor is a great place to consider for your next home search.

Be the first to know when new properties in Randall Manor become available. Register with us for free to get exclusive access to new listings and receive notifications when new homes hit the market!

Randall Manor Entertainment and Amenities

Randall Manor also offers a fair bit of leisure and culture to its residents without having to travel far. The neighborhood is adjacent to Sailors Snug Harbor, which hosts a variety of artistic and educational programs throughout the year. Additionally, the nearby New Brighton and West Brighton offer their ranges of dining and shopping options for locals.

For those who love the outdoors, you’ll also find several green spaces relatively close to Randall Manor. The expansive Snug Harbor Cultural Center and Botanical Garden, just to the North, provide residents with even more opportunities for relaxation and recreation. The area also benefits from being close to St. George Theatre and the Staten Island Museum, which are also a wealth of artistic and historical resources.

Education Near Randall Manor

Randall Manor is served by a few well-regarded public and private schooling options. The local schools are known to provide a great educational foundation. Public schools in the area, such as P.S. 45 John Tyler and I.S. 61 William A Morris, are usually where students in the area attend. This is complemented by private options like Our Lady of Good Counsel, providing comprehensive educational choices.

Higher education is also accessible with several colleges close by, including the College of Staten Island and Wagner College, which offer a range of undergraduate and graduate programs. If you’re considering a move within Staten Island, and having access to high-quality education is on your priority list, you should consider Randall Manor as an option.

Randall Manor FAQ

Q: What transportation options are available in Randall Manor?

A: Randall Manor is well-served by public transit options. Key bus routes include the S48 and S98 on Forest Avenue, the S46 and S96 on Castleton Avenue, and the S44 and S94 on Henderson Avenue, with the SIM30 express bus providing direct access to Manhattan. Of course, you can also easily access the St. George Ferry Terminal for additional access to Manhattan.

Q: How walkable is Randall Manor?

A: Randall Manor is moderately walkable, with many daily needs accessible within a short walk. The neighborhood’s flat terrain and quiet streets make it pleasant for walking, especially for families and elderly residents. For more extensive shopping and dining, however, public transport or a personal vehicle would be best.

Q: What healthcare facilities are available near Randall Manor?

A: You’ll have access to a few healthcare facilities around Randall Manor. Staten Island University Hospital is nearby, which covers most of your bases. There are also quite a few clinics and specialized healthcare providers within the area, as well.

Staten Island Neighborhoods

Homes for sale in
Annadale, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Arden Heights, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Arlington, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Arrochar, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Bay Terrace, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Bloomfield, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Bulls Head, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Butler Manor, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Castleton Corners, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Charleston, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Clifton, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Clove Lake, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Concord, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Dongan Hills, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Dongan Hills Above the Boulevard, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Dongan Hills Below the Boulevard, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Dongan Hills Colony, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Elm Park, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Eltingville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Emerson Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Emerson Valley, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Fort Wadsworth, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Graniteville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Grant City, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Grasmere, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Great Kills, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Grymes Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Heartland Village, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
High Rock, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Huguenot, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Latourette, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Lighthouse Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Livingston, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Lower Todt Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Manor Heights, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Mariners Harbor, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Meiers Corners, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Midland Beach, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
New Brighton, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
New Dorp, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
New Dorp Beach, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
New Dorp Heights, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
New Springville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Oakwood, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Old Town, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Park Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Pleasant Plains, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Port Richmond, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Prince’s Bay, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Randall Manor, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Richmond Valley, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Richmondtown, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Rosebank, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Rossville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
S.E. Annadale, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Shore Acres, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Silver Lake, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Snug Harbor, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
South Beach, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
St. George, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Stapleton, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Sunnyside, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Sunset Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Todt Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Tompkinsville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Travis, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Ward Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
West Brighton, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Westerleigh, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Willowbrook, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Woodrow, Staten Island, NY

Start searching for your dream home now.

When it comes to convenience, our site is unparalleled. Whether you’re in the comfort of your home, or on the go.
Our site works flawlessly on multiple devices so you can find the information you need.

Start Search

Latest Listings

16 Fieldway Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10308

$739,888

16 Fieldway Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10308
MLS#: 2502904
Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc.
462 52nd Street 2D, Brooklyn, New York, 11220

$628,000

462 52nd Street 2D, Brooklyn, New York, 11220
MLS#: 492847
7 Manor Court, Old Bridge, NJ, 08857

$875,000

7 Manor Court, Old Bridge, NJ, 08857
MLS#: 22514993
3 Larrabee Boulevard, Howell, NJ, 07731

$720,000

3 Larrabee Boulevard, Howell, NJ, 07731
MLS#: 22514988
128 Freeport Boulevard, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$369,900

128 Freeport Boulevard, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 22514990
44 Gardenia Way, Toms River, NJ, 08755

$275,000

44 Gardenia Way, Toms River, NJ, 08755
MLS#: 22514984
5 Stratford Drive, Manalapan, NJ, 07726

$739,000

5 Stratford Drive, Manalapan, NJ, 07726
MLS#: 22514991
624 Lloyd Road, Aberdeen, NJ, 07747

$589,900

624 Lloyd Road, Aberdeen, NJ, 07747
MLS#: 22514985
30 Kent Drive, Brick, NJ, 08723

$429,000

30 Kent Drive, Brick, NJ, 08723
MLS#: 22513008
225 Buermann Avenue, Toms River, NJ, 08753

$454,900

225 Buermann Avenue, Toms River, NJ, 08753
MLS#: 22512901
84 E Cliff Road, Colonia, NJ, 07067

$899,000

84 E Cliff Road, Colonia, NJ, 07067
MLS#: 2513957R
14 Fisher Avenue, Middlesex, NJ, 08846

$599,000

14 Fisher Avenue, Middlesex, NJ, 08846
MLS#: 2561632M
7 Manor Court, Old Bridge, NJ, 08857

$875,000

7 Manor Court, Old Bridge, NJ, 08857
MLS#: 2514034R
10 N Wood Avenue 215, Linden, NJ, 07036

$234,999

10 N Wood Avenue 215, Linden, NJ, 07036
MLS#: 2514051R
30 Arbutus Way, Staten Island, NY, 10312

$1,499,000

30 Arbutus Way, Staten Island, NY, 10312
MLS#: 2502908
441 Slocum Place, Oakhurst, NJ, 07755

$1,750,000

441 Slocum Place, Oakhurst, NJ, 07755
MLS#: 22514982
166 Grayson Avenue, Hamilton, NJ, 08619

$549,000

166 Grayson Avenue, Hamilton, NJ, 08619
MLS#: 22514976
6 Bella Court, Manalapan, NJ, 07726

$686,470

6 Bella Court, Manalapan, NJ, 07726
MLS#: 22514955
75 Meadowview Drive 2203, Annandale, NJ, 08801

$285,000

75 Meadowview Drive 2203, Annandale, NJ, 08801
MLS#: 22514956
10 Pepperidge Road, Howell, NJ, 07731

$899,999

10 Pepperidge Road, Howell, NJ, 07731
MLS#: 22514974
36C Haddon Road, Monroe, NJ, 08831

$409,000

36C Haddon Road, Monroe, NJ, 08831
MLS#: 22514964
8 Wycombe Court, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$444,900

8 Wycombe Court, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 22514973
4403 Galloping Hill Lane, Toms River, NJ, 08755

$529,000

4403 Galloping Hill Lane, Toms River, NJ, 08755
MLS#: 22514961
97 Dollmore Avenue, Waretown, NJ, 08758

$349,900

97 Dollmore Avenue, Waretown, NJ, 08758
MLS#: 22514957
33 Red Maple Drive, Brick, NJ, 08724

$650,000

33 Red Maple Drive, Brick, NJ, 08724
MLS#: 22514966
810 Blenheim Drive, Brick, NJ, 08724

$710,000

810 Blenheim Drive, Brick, NJ, 08724
MLS#: 22514963
18 Neptune Place, North Middletown, NJ, 07748

$859,000

18 Neptune Place, North Middletown, NJ, 07748
MLS#: 22514981
6 Cardinal Way, Raritan, NJ, 08869

$650,000

6 Cardinal Way, Raritan, NJ, 08869
MLS#: 22514962
10 Merrilee Lane, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$399,900

10 Merrilee Lane, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 22514970
14 Winterton Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$439,000

14 Winterton Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 22514977
65 Creek Road 419, Brick, NJ, 08724

$300,000

65 Creek Road 419, Brick, NJ, 08724
MLS#: 22514954
72 Storm Jib Court, Bayville, NJ, 08721

$625,000

72 Storm Jib Court, Bayville, NJ, 08721
MLS#: 22509331
1020 Clubhouse Drive, Forked River, NJ, 08731

$330,000

1020 Clubhouse Drive, Forked River, NJ, 08731
MLS#: 22508018
45 Royal Drive, Brick, NJ, 08723

$1,399,999

45 Royal Drive, Brick, NJ, 08723
MLS#: 22506433
160 Evergreen Road 6A, Edison, NJ, 08837

$239,900

160 Evergreen Road 6A, Edison, NJ, 08837
MLS#: 2514041R
10 Ritter Road, South Brunswick, NJ, 08824

$524,900

10 Ritter Road, South Brunswick, NJ, 08824
MLS#: 2561572M
796 Sparta Road D, Monroe, NJ, 08831

$349,900

796 Sparta Road D, Monroe, NJ, 08831
MLS#: 2513945R
36-C Haddon Road, Monroe, NJ, 08831

$409,000

36-C Haddon Road, Monroe, NJ, 08831
MLS#: 2514001R
5 Ave B, Staten Island, NY, 10302

$529,000

5 Ave B, Staten Island, NY, 10302
MLS#: 2502907
211 Cedar Avenue, Long Branch, NJ, 07740

$9,900,000

211 Cedar Avenue, Long Branch, NJ, 07740
MLS#: 22514949
136 Pacific Avenue, Beachwood, NJ, 08722

$479,888

136 Pacific Avenue, Beachwood, NJ, 08722
MLS#: 22514942
1915 Switzer Avenue 1915, Parlin, NJ, 08859

$619,999

1915 Switzer Avenue 1915, Parlin, NJ, 08859
MLS#: 22514948
8 Primrose Court, Manalapan, NJ, 07726

$718,070

8 Primrose Court, Manalapan, NJ, 07726
MLS#: 22514950
231 Friendship Road, Howell, NJ, 07731

$2,200,000

231 Friendship Road, Howell, NJ, 07731
MLS#: 22514943
201 Sunset Avenue 110, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712

$1,099,990

201 Sunset Avenue 110, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712
MLS#: 22514934
6 Langley Road, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$225,000

6 Langley Road, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 22514936
13 John Street, Hazlet, NJ, 07730

$149,999

13 John Street, Hazlet, NJ, 07730
MLS#: 22514926
11 Clay Street, West Long Branch, NJ, 07764

$1,499,000

11 Clay Street, West Long Branch, NJ, 07764
MLS#: 22514922
48 Scarborough Court 7, Freehold, NJ, 07728

$425,000

48 Scarborough Court 7, Freehold, NJ, 07728
MLS#: 22514923
6 Barend Street, Millville, NJ, 08332

$289,000

6 Barend Street, Millville, NJ, 08332
MLS#: 22514927
22 Commons Drive, Neptune Township, NJ, 07753

$495,000

22 Commons Drive, Neptune Township, NJ, 07753
MLS#: 22514924
28 Twyford Lane, Manchester, NJ, 08759

$439,900

28 Twyford Lane, Manchester, NJ, 08759
MLS#: 22514946
9 Pine Grove Avenue, Manahawkin, NJ, 08050

$315,000

9 Pine Grove Avenue, Manahawkin, NJ, 08050
MLS#: 22514945
700 Ocean Avenue 514, Spring Lake, NJ, 07762

$765,000

700 Ocean Avenue 514, Spring Lake, NJ, 07762
MLS#: 22514919
2805 Kapalua Court, Freehold, NJ, 07728

$499,990

2805 Kapalua Court, Freehold, NJ, 07728
MLS#: 22514925
151 Shore Drive, Brick, NJ, 08723

$849,000

151 Shore Drive, Brick, NJ, 08723
MLS#: 22514953
510 Deal Lake Drive 5J, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712

$545,000

510 Deal Lake Drive 5J, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712
MLS#: 22514951
585 Allen Road, Brick, NJ, 08723

$529,000

585 Allen Road, Brick, NJ, 08723
MLS#: 22514935
23 Vought Avenue, Freehold, NJ, 07728

$400,000

23 Vought Avenue, Freehold, NJ, 07728
MLS#: 22514928
6 Muravski Court, South River, NJ, 08882

$649,000

6 Muravski Court, South River, NJ, 08882
MLS#: 22514921
29 Campview Place, Keansburg, NJ, 07734

$540,000

29 Campview Place, Keansburg, NJ, 07734
MLS#: 22514937
1316 Ocean Avenue, Point Pleasant Beach, NJ, 08742

$1,250,000

1316 Ocean Avenue, Point Pleasant Beach, NJ, 08742
MLS#: 22514941
123 Nautilus Drive, Manahawkin, NJ, 08050

$450,000

123 Nautilus Drive, Manahawkin, NJ, 08050
MLS#: 22514123
281 Old Toms River Road, Brick, NJ, 08723

$519,000

281 Old Toms River Road, Brick, NJ, 08723
MLS#: 22514938
1118 Jeffrey Street, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712

$753,000

1118 Jeffrey Street, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712
MLS#: 22514940
1603 Dorsett Dock Road, Point Pleasant, NJ, 08742

$599,900

1603 Dorsett Dock Road, Point Pleasant, NJ, 08742
MLS#: 22506911
25 Robbins Street, Brick, NJ, 08724

$1,148,500

25 Robbins Street, Brick, NJ, 08724
MLS#: 22505795
497 Skylark Drive, Monroe, NJ, 08831

$450,000

497 Skylark Drive, Monroe, NJ, 08831
MLS#: 2513872R
299 Riva Avenue, East Brunswick, NJ, 08850

$629,990

299 Riva Avenue, East Brunswick, NJ, 08850
MLS#: 2513940R
47 Wild Turkey Way, Manalapan, NJ, 07726

$399,000

47 Wild Turkey Way, Manalapan, NJ, 07726
MLS#: 2514028R
3223 Banta Road, South Plainfield, NJ, 07080

$890,000

3223 Banta Road, South Plainfield, NJ, 07080
MLS#: 2513771R
9 Jared Drive, Robbinsville, NJ, 08691

$999,900

9 Jared Drive, Robbinsville, NJ, 08691
MLS#: 2513933R
25 Clover Avenue, Colonia, NJ, 07067

$569,000

25 Clover Avenue, Colonia, NJ, 07067
MLS#: 2561637M
15 Woodhill Street 146, Franklin, NJ, 08873

$499,900

15 Woodhill Street 146, Franklin, NJ, 08873
MLS#: 2513912R
84 N Main Street, Cranbury, NJ, 08512

$750,000

84 N Main Street, Cranbury, NJ, 08512
MLS#: 2514011R
37 Brewer Way 34, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536

$945,593

37 Brewer Way 34, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536
MLS#: 2514023R
39 Brewer Way 33, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536

$878,050

39 Brewer Way 33, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536
MLS#: 2514022R
35 Brewer Way 35, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536

$883,032

35 Brewer Way 35, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536
MLS#: 2514020R
33 Orchard Road, Middlesex, NJ, 08846

$549,900

33 Orchard Road, Middlesex, NJ, 08846
MLS#: 2514014R
694 Vincent Place, Perth Amboy, NJ, 08861

$499,000

694 Vincent Place, Perth Amboy, NJ, 08861
MLS#: 2513924R
98 S Cliff Road, Colonia, NJ, 07067

$675,000

98 S Cliff Road, Colonia, NJ, 07067
MLS#: 2513688R
33 Brewer Way 36, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536

$857,902

33 Brewer Way 36, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536
MLS#: 2514016R
31 Brewer Way 37, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536

$868,176

31 Brewer Way 37, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536
MLS#: 2514015R
7 Flemmer Court 19, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536

$839,990

7 Flemmer Court 19, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536
MLS#: 2514013R
(718) 987-7900