Tottenville

Tottenville has many well-kept Victorian houses from the 1800s. These old homes give the area a special look. Tottenville sits next to the Arthur Kill waterway. People living here can see beautiful water views and sunsets. They can also enjoy activities on the water.

Real Estate Statistics

Average Price	$1.2M
Lowest Price	$369K
Highest Price	$3.4M
Total Listings	47
Avg. Days on Market	76
Avg. Price/SQFT	$502

Property Types
(active listings)

Homes For Sale In Tottenville

Sort by:

$855,000

220 Sprague Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

4 BEDS 2 BATHS 2,033 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 492844

$855,000

220 Sprague Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 2 BATHS 2,033 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502866

$799,000

5 Sprague Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,512 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Semi-Attached MLS ® # 2502837

$880,000

88 Meagan Loop, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 4 BATHS 2,160 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502806

$1,200,000

5407 Arthur Kill Road Road, Staten Island, NY, 10307

6 BEDS 5 BATHS 2,440 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502792

$1,999,999

261 Chelsea Street, Staten Island, New York, 10307

4,286 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 492693

$799,000

230 Bedell Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

2 BEDS 1 BATHS 700 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502721

$999,999

20 Averill Place, Staten Island, NY, 10307

7 BEDS 5 BATHS 4,000 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2501723

$799,000

230 Bedell Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

2 BEDS 1 BATHS 700 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 492647

$4,600,000

30 Aviva Court, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 5 BATHS 7,313 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502701

$649,000

668 Yetman Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

2 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,092 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2501501

$1,350,000

197 Aspinwall Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 6 BATHS 2,520 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2500760

$2,999,000

64 Ottavio Promenade, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 5 BATHS 4,914 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502651

$1,379,000

191 Finlay Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 4 BATHS 3,500 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2402981

$1,625,000

101 Bedell Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

4 BEDS 5 BATHS 3,540 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 492566

$1,999,999

261 Chelsea Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

5 BEDS 2 BATHS 5,460 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502629

$995,000

526 Yetman Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

4 BEDS 4 BATHS 2,700 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 492491

$995,000

526 Yetman Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 4 BATHS 2,700 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502618

$1,450,000

376 Manhattan Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 3 BATHS 4,075 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502610

$1,379,000

6 Hale Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

5 BEDS 4 BATHS 3,350 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2500390

$1,035,000

66 Joline Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 3 BATHS 2,037 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502174

$1,299,900

183 Brighton Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

5 BEDS 5 BATHS 2,226 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502572

$1,249,999

170 Brehaut Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 3 BATHS 3,030 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2501655

$424,000

110 Surfside Plaza 88, Staten Island, NY, 10307

2 BEDS 1 BATHS 1,310 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Attached MLS ® # 2502515

$555,000

42 Girard Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,800 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Attached MLS ® # 2502510

$710,000

284 Chelsea Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 2 BATHS 2,475 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 1161922

$555,000

241 Loretto Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

2 BEDS 2 BATHS 992 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Attached MLS ® # 2502422

$799,000

195 Yetman Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,824 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502401

$849,000

110-112 Johnson Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 4 BATHS 2,840 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502413

$1,385,000

394 Page Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

4 BEDS 4 BATHS 2,809 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 492238

$1,035,000

66 Joline Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

Multi-Family MLS ® # 490982

$1,625,000

21 Sprague Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

Multi-Family MLS ® # 490784

$1,850,000

131 Hopping Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

5 BEDS 5 BATHS 5,104 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 490703

$649,000

668 Yetman Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

2 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,100 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 490223

$1,350,000

197 Aspinwall Street, Staten Island, New York, 10307

4 BEDS 6 BATHS 2,520 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 489966

$2,299,999

90 Giegerich Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

5 BEDS 5,760 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 489782

$680,000

30 Conference Court, Staten Island, New York, 10307

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 2,100 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 489396

$1,149,000

43 Lerer Lane, Staten Island, New York, 10307

4 BEDS 4 BATHS 2,500 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 488944

$948,000

147 Wood Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,872 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502360

$1,385,000

394 Page Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 4 BATHS 2,809 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502356

$1,299,999

165 Chelsea Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 2,820 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502265

$665,000

4 Wood Lane, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 2,550 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502234

$3,100,000

14 Ottavio Promenade, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 7 BATHS 10,200 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502226

$1,500,888

7 Parker Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

5 BEDS 4 BATHS 2,330 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502132

$799,000

171 Lee Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 808 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2502105

$1,350,000

660 Rockaway Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 4 BATHS 2,112 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2501975

$1,849,000

561 Rockaway Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 5 BATHS 3,000 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2501937

$1,999,000

503 Bedell Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 5 BATHS 5,200 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2501771

$2,549,000

35 Jeffrey Place, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 6 BATHS 5,200 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2501546

$949,000

63 Chelsea Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

6 BEDS 1 BATHS 2,420 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2501537

$829,000

56 Bentley Lane, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,450 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Attached MLS ® # 2501477

$599,999

36 Winding Woods Loop, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,100 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Attached MLS ® # 2501223

$2,299,999

90 Giegerich Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

5 BEDS 3 BATHS 5,760 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2501198

$1,925,000

11 Lulu Court, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 4 BATHS 3,400 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Semi-Attached MLS ® # 2500949

$1,875,000

30 Paradise Place, Staten Island, NY, 10307

5 BEDS 4 BATHS 3,500 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2500865

$1,288,000

137 Butler Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

6 BEDS 2 BATHS 3,000 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2500734

$1,328,000

133 Butler Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

6 BEDS 2 BATHS 3,000 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2500732

$1,288,000

141 Butler Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

6 BEDS 2 BATHS 3,000 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2500733

$949,800

443 Manhattan Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,530 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2500679

$865,000

176 Camden Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10309

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,500 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Semi-Attached MLS ® # 2405547

$2,999,000

64 Ottavio Promenade, Staten Island, New York, 10307

4 BEDS 5 BATHS 4,914 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 487020

$1,099,999

303 Sprague Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 2,700 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 486572

$1,329,900

178 Chelsea Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

6 BEDS 5 BATHS 2,384 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2403201

$680,000

30 Conference Court, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 2,100 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Attached MLS ® # 2500210

$875,000

269 Fisher Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,440 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 487963

$1,399,000

535 Craig Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 4 BATHS 3,818 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2406402

$950,000

174 Wood Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10307

4 BATHS 2,900 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 487333

$619,888

11 Chelsea Street, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,184 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2404993

$1,500,000

7372 Amboy Road Road, Staten Island, NY, 10307

4 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,800 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2404184

$1,050,000

303 Sprague Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10307

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 2,700 BUILDING SQFT Two Family - Detached MLS ® # 2403937

Discover Homes for Sale in Tottenville, Staten Island

Tottenville, located at the southern tip of Staten Island, offers a unique blend of suburban living and rich history. If you’re searching for homes for sale in Tottenville, Staten Island, you’ll find a community with much to offer.

Real Estate Market Overview

Median Home Sale Price: $850,000 (an 8.1% increase from last year)
Average Days on Market: 36 days (down from 66 days)
Sale-to-List Price Ratio: 97.7%
Monthly Housing Costs: Median of $2,166
Home Ownership: 78.93% owner-occupied

Tottenville’s real estate market is thriving, with a median home sale price of $850,000, reflecting an 8.1% increase from last year. Homes here sell quickly, with an average of 36 days on the market and a sale-to-list price ratio of 97.7%. The majority of residents own their homes, creating a stable and welcoming environment.

Be the first to know when new properties in Tottenville become available. Register with us for free to get exclusive access to new listings and receive notifications when new homes hit the market!

Community and Lifestyle

Population: 14,517 residents
Median Age: 42 years
Family Households: 75.2%
Primary Language: English spoken in 84.6% of households
Cultural Heritage: Strong Italian roots, with 39.7% claiming Italian ancestry

Tottenville is a family-friendly neighborhood with a diverse cultural background. The community values education and maintains a welcoming atmosphere for new residents.

Employment and Income

Median Household Income: $112,484
Employment Sectors:
- Private Companies: 54.45%
- Government: 30.97%
- Self-Employed: 7.46%
Job Types:
- White Collar: 80.09%
- Blue Collar: 19.91%

Tottenville residents enjoy a robust job market with opportunities in both private and public sectors. The median household income is $112,484. Employment is divided among private companies (54.45%), government (30.97%), and self-employed individuals (7.46%). The majority of jobs (80.09%) are in white-collar professions.

Education

Education is highly valued in Tottenville. The community has a strong educational attainment record:

High School Graduates: 30.19%
College Certificate Holders: 22.9%
Bachelor’s Degree Holders: 21.63%

Many residents holding college degrees or certificates. Local schools are well-regarded, contributing to the community’s emphasis on learning.

Transportation

Tottenville offers convenient transportation options for residents:

Staten Island Railway: Terminus at Tottenville station
Express Bus Service: Available for commuters
Major Roads: Access via Arthur Kill Road and Amboy Road

Transportation options make commuting straightforward, whether you’re traveling by train, bus, or car. The Staten Island Railway connects Tottenville to other parts of the island, enhancing its accessibility.

Historical and Recreational Sites

Conference House: Historic site of the 1776 Revolutionary War peace conference
Parks and Preserves:
- Conference House Park
- Tottenville Shoreline Preserve
- Quick Point Nature Preserve

Tottenville’s rich history adds to its charm. Residents enjoy waterfront views of Raritan Bay and have access to several parks and nature preserves for outdoor activities.

Why Tottenville is a Great Place to Live

With its strong sense of community, excellent schools, and variety of housing options, Tottenville is an attractive choice for homebuyers. The area’s historical significance and natural beauty offer a pleasant living environment.

Explore Homes for Sale in Tottenville Today

If you’re interested in joining this vibrant community, consider exploring the homes for sale in Tottenville, Staten Island. With a thriving real estate market and much to offer, Tottenville could be the perfect place for your next home.

Staten Island Neighborhoods

Start searching for your dream home now.

When it comes to convenience, our site is unparalleled. Whether you’re in the comfort of your home, or on the go.
Our site works flawlessly on multiple devices so you can find the information you need.

Start Search

Latest Listings