Skip to content

Homes For Sale In Eltingville

Eltingville

Eltingville is located on Staten Island’s South Shore, and known for its rich history and excellent community life. It serves as a bridge between the past and present, where Scandinavian roots and modern day Italian-American culture blend effortlessly. The area is characterized by its main commercial stretches along Richmond Avenue, Amboy Road, and Hylan Boulevard, making it a place for activity and commerce.

Eltingville Real Estate Statistics

Average Price $866K
Lowest Price $310K
Highest Price $3M
Total Listings 40
Avg. Days on Market 72
Avg. Price/SQFT $547

Property Types
(active listings)

Homes For Sale In Eltingville

Sort by:

$310,000

125 Cortelyou Avenue 1-2, Staten Island, NY, 10308

1 BEDS 1 BATHS 741 BUILDING SQFT Apartment MLS ® # 2403561

$445,000

254 Katan Avenue #B, Staten Island, NY, 10308

2 BEDS 1 BATHS 1,296 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Attached MLS ® # 2502530

$499,000

319 Winchester Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312

2 BEDS 1 BATHS 910 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Detached MLS ® # 2500943

$549,999

75 Chesebrough Street, Staten Island, NY, 10312

2 BEDS 2 BATHS 2,001 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Attached MLS ® # 2502426

$565,000

14 Village Lane B, Staten Island, NY, 10312

2 BEDS 1 BATHS 1,400 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Attached MLS ® # 2502368

$599,000

76 Wilson Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10308

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,334 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Semi-Attached MLS ® # 2502880

$599,000

31 Ray Street, Staten Island, NY, 10312

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,280 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Semi-Attached MLS ® # 2502266

$599,000

285 Bartlett Avenue, Staten Island, New York, 10312

2 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,400 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 490314

$599,000

285 Bartlett Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312

2 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,480 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Attached MLS ® # 2501571

$599,900

48 Robinson Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312

2 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,620 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Semi-Attached MLS ® # 2502688

$599,900

34 Filipe Lane B, Staten Island, NY, 10308

2 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,350 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Attached MLS ® # 2502040

$599,999

61 E Figurea Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10308

4 BEDS 3 BATHS 2,288 BUILDING SQFT Single Family - Semi-Attached MLS ® # 2502347

About Eltingville

Eltingville’s history dates back to when it was known as South Side and later Seaside, painting a picture of a neighborhood that’s always been at the hear of Staten Island’s development. The transformation from a railway terminus to a suburban residential area following the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge showcases its focus on growth and adaptability. Today, Eltingville is a fantastic example of the cultural heritage that shaped it, from its early Scandinavian settlers to the thriving Italian-American community that now calls it home. The neighborhood’s evolution is mirrored in its architecture, from historic homes to modern constructions, and in its busy commercial areas that cater to range of interests and needs.

Eltingville Homes For Sale

There’s a diverse and desirable real estate landscape in Eltingville. Prospective homebuyers can find a variety of homes, from charming older models that reflect the area’s early 20th-century Scandinavian influence to newer, more contemporary residences. The neighborhood is particularly known for its spacious, single-family homes, many of which come with sizable yards perfect for families. Additionally, Eltingville offers a selection of townhouses providing options for those seeking a more communal living experience or a first-time homebuyer looking for an entry point into the market. The variety of housing ensures that there’s something for everyone, from those looking for the character of an older home, or a more modern place to call home.

The types of homes for sale in Eltingville also include properties that are ideal for those interested in custom renovations. Many homes in the area offer the potential for personalization, allowing buyers to put in their own stamp on a piece of Staten Island’s history. Whether it’s a classic Cape Cod needing a modern touch or a mid-century ranch waiting to be transformed, Eltingville provides a canvas for those looking to create their dream home in a neighborhood rich with character and community spirit.

Be the first to know when new properties in Eltingville become available. Register with us for free to get exclusive access to new listings and receive notifications when new homes hit the market!

Eltingville Entertainment & Amenities

Beyond the homes, Eltingville also offers a great lifestyle for its residents. The neighborhood is home to a variety of dining options, from traditional Italian eateries reflecting its large Italian-American population to newer, diverse culinary offerings. Shopping enthusiasts will find everything from local boutiques to large retail outlets along the main commercial thoroughfares, providing a convenient and varied shopping experience. For outdoor enthusiasts, Eltingville offers easy access to several parks and beaches, making it easy to enjoy Staten Island’s natural beauty.

The entertainment options in Eltingville extend beyond dining and shopping. The neighborhood offers a range of recreational activities, including sports fields, playgrounds, and community centers, offering activities for all ages. Cultural events, community gatherings, and local festivals further enrich the opportunities here. With its residential appeal, and community-focused amenities, those seeking a fulfilling life in Staten Island can find that in Eltingville.

Staten Island Neighborhoods

Homes for sale in
Annadale, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Arden Heights, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Arlington, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Arrochar, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Bay Terrace, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Bloomfield, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Bulls Head, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Butler Manor, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Castleton Corners, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Charleston, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Clifton, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Clove Lake, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Concord, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Dongan Hills, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Dongan Hills Above the Boulevard, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Dongan Hills Below the Boulevard, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Dongan Hills Colony, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Elm Park, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Eltingville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Emerson Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Emerson Valley, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Fort Wadsworth, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Graniteville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Grant City, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Grasmere, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Great Kills, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Grymes Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Heartland Village, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
High Rock, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Huguenot, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Latourette, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Lighthouse Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Livingston, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Lower Todt Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Manor Heights, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Mariners Harbor, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Meiers Corners, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Midland Beach, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
New Brighton, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
New Dorp, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
New Dorp Beach, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
New Dorp Heights, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
New Springville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Oakwood, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Old Town, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Park Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Pleasant Plains, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Port Richmond, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Prince’s Bay, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Randall Manor, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Richmond Valley, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Richmondtown, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Rosebank, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Rossville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
S.E. Annadale, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Shore Acres, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Silver Lake, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Snug Harbor, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
South Beach, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
St. George, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Stapleton, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Sunnyside, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Sunset Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Todt Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Tompkinsville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Travis, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Ward Hill, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
West Brighton, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Westerleigh, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Willowbrook, Staten Island, NY
Homes for sale in
Woodrow, Staten Island, NY

Start searching for your dream home now.

When it comes to convenience, our site is unparalleled. Whether you’re in the comfort of your home, or on the go.
Our site works flawlessly on multiple devices so you can find the information you need.

Start Search

Latest Listings

65 Newberry Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10304

$869,900

65 Newberry Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10304
MLS#: 2502914
Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc.
3350 E washington road Road, Parlin, NJ, 08859

$465,000

3350 E washington road Road, Parlin, NJ, 08859
MLS#: 2514067R
2291 Morrison Avenue, Union Twp, NJ, 07083

$699,000

2291 Morrison Avenue, Union Twp, NJ, 07083
MLS#: 2514068R
8113 Tamarron Drive, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536

$299,900

8113 Tamarron Drive, Plainsboro, NJ, 08536
MLS#: 2513963R
1 Birch Ct Court, Monroe, NJ, 08831

$849,000

1 Birch Ct Court, Monroe, NJ, 08831
MLS#: 2511616R
312 Bunnell Place, Lacey, NJ, 08731

$350,000

312 Bunnell Place, Lacey, NJ, 08731
MLS#: 2514048R
184 Freeborn Street, Staten Island, NY, 10306

$499,000

184 Freeborn Street, Staten Island, NY, 10306
MLS#: 2502917
182 Freeborn Street, Staten Island, NY, 10306

$499,000

182 Freeborn Street, Staten Island, NY, 10306
MLS#: 2502916
24 Arielle Lane 136, Staten Island, NY, 10314

$450,000

24 Arielle Lane 136, Staten Island, NY, 10314
MLS#: 2502915
35 Futurity Place, Staten Island, NY, 10312

$709,888

35 Futurity Place, Staten Island, NY, 10312
MLS#: 2502919
46 Buttonwood Road, Staten Island, NY, 10304

$2,250,000

46 Buttonwood Road, Staten Island, NY, 10304
MLS#: 2502913
566 Hunter Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306

$399,000

566 Hunter Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306
MLS#: 2502918
353 Cheves Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314

$775,000

353 Cheves Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314
MLS#: 2501670
45 Scott Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10305

$685,000

45 Scott Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10305
MLS#: 2405157

$2,150,000

620 Ocean Terrace, Staten Island, New York, 10301
MLS#: 492908

$1,325,000

2544 East 64th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234
MLS#: 492907
31-53 Linden Place 4B, Flushing, New York, 11354

$680,000

31-53 Linden Place 4B, Flushing, New York, 11354
MLS#: 492904
46 Buttonwood Road, Staten  Island, New York, 10304

$2,250,000

46 Buttonwood Road, Staten Island, New York, 10304
MLS#: 492903
9511 Shore Road 617, Brooklyn, New York, 11209

$450,000

9511 Shore Road 617, Brooklyn, New York, 11209
MLS#: 492901
2077 East 22nd Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11229

$1,275,000

2077 East 22nd Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11229
MLS#: 492892
1540 East 45th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

$899,000

1540 East 45th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234
MLS#: 492888
1625 Emmons Avenue 6T, Brooklyn, New York, 11235

$339,000

1625 Emmons Avenue 6T, Brooklyn, New York, 11235
MLS#: 489452
1580 East 13th Street 7G, Brooklyn, New York, 11230

$210,000

1580 East 13th Street 7G, Brooklyn, New York, 11230
MLS#: 489110
312 Bunnell Place, Forked River, NJ, 08731

$350,000

312 Bunnell Place, Forked River, NJ, 08731
MLS#: 22515044
128 Birch Avenue, Little Silver, NJ, 07739

$898,500

128 Birch Avenue, Little Silver, NJ, 07739
MLS#: 22515043
639 Madison Drive C, Monroe, NJ, 08831

$360,000

639 Madison Drive C, Monroe, NJ, 08831
MLS#: 2514059R
1204 Maplecrest Road, Edison, NJ, 08820

$489,000

1204 Maplecrest Road, Edison, NJ, 08820
MLS#: 2514062R
5448 Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island, NY, 10307

$1,699,000

5448 Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island, NY, 10307
MLS#: 2502911
2366 East 29th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11229

$999,900

2366 East 29th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11229
MLS#: 492881
2182 East 36th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

$1,150,000

2182 East 36th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234
MLS#: 492871
1905 Clove Road, Staten  Island, New York, 10304

$850,000

1905 Clove Road, Staten Island, New York, 10304
MLS#: 492754
62 Westgate Place, Manchester, NJ, 08759

$375,000

62 Westgate Place, Manchester, NJ, 08759
MLS#: 22515038
668 Clifton Avenue, Toms River, NJ, 08753

$550,000

668 Clifton Avenue, Toms River, NJ, 08753
MLS#: 22515025
141 Cranmoor Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08753

$1,800,000

141 Cranmoor Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08753
MLS#: 22515028
45 Brookfield Drive, Jackson, NJ, 08527

$545,000

45 Brookfield Drive, Jackson, NJ, 08527
MLS#: 22515029
1144 Deal Road, Ocean Twp, NJ, 07712

$879,000

1144 Deal Road, Ocean Twp, NJ, 07712
MLS#: 22515030
300 Lareine Avenue, Bradley Beach, NJ, 07720

$1,650,000

300 Lareine Avenue, Bradley Beach, NJ, 07720
MLS#: 22515024
240 Bennington Road, Freehold, NJ, 07728

$1,249,000

240 Bennington Road, Freehold, NJ, 07728
MLS#: 22515026
28 Riverside Avenue 9G, Red Bank, NJ, 07701

$545,000

28 Riverside Avenue 9G, Red Bank, NJ, 07701
MLS#: 22515031
68 Seneca Place, Oceanport, NJ, 07757

$2,999,999

68 Seneca Place, Oceanport, NJ, 07757
MLS#: 22515037
70 Clark Avenue, Ocean Grove, NJ, 07756

$799,000

70 Clark Avenue, Ocean Grove, NJ, 07756
MLS#: 22515036
156 Chelsea Avenue, Long Branch, NJ, 07740

$1,325,000

156 Chelsea Avenue, Long Branch, NJ, 07740
MLS#: 22515033
143 Westbrook Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$298,900

143 Westbrook Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 22515042
476 Birch Bark Drive, Brick, NJ, 08723

$769,000

476 Birch Bark Drive, Brick, NJ, 08723
MLS#: 22515039
35 Tara Lin Drive, Hazlet, NJ, 07730

$475,000

35 Tara Lin Drive, Hazlet, NJ, 07730
MLS#: 22515032
1254B Hamilton Court, Lakewood, NJ, 08701

$180,000

1254B Hamilton Court, Lakewood, NJ, 08701
MLS#: 22507091
91 Ridge Road, Rumson, NJ, 07760

$3,500,000

91 Ridge Road, Rumson, NJ, 07760
MLS#: 22515040
1402 Violet Lane, Jackson, NJ, 08527

$374,900

1402 Violet Lane, Jackson, NJ, 08527
MLS#: 22505894
2 Jayne Street, Old Bridge, NJ, 08857

$599,900

2 Jayne Street, Old Bridge, NJ, 08857
MLS#: 2513737R
1 Cristina Court, Old Bridge, NJ, 07747

$970,000

1 Cristina Court, Old Bridge, NJ, 07747
MLS#: 2514064R
6 Thrush Court, Old Bridge, NJ, 08857

$775,000

6 Thrush Court, Old Bridge, NJ, 08857
MLS#: 2514054R
71 Russell Street, Woodbridge Proper, NJ, 07095

$445,000

71 Russell Street, Woodbridge Proper, NJ, 07095
MLS#: 2561635M
416 Wallace Street 416, Edison, NJ, 08817

$499,900

416 Wallace Street 416, Edison, NJ, 08817
MLS#: 2561609M
5 Alvin Court, Menlo Park Terrace, NJ, 08840

$750,000

5 Alvin Court, Menlo Park Terrace, NJ, 08840
MLS#: 2513867R
369 N Main Street, Milltown, NJ, 08850

$599,900

369 N Main Street, Milltown, NJ, 08850
MLS#: 2513970R
38 Point Pleasant Lane, Waretown, NJ, 08758

$649,900

38 Point Pleasant Lane, Waretown, NJ, 08758
MLS#: 22515017
125 Bloomfield Road, Barnegat, NJ, 08005

$825,000

125 Bloomfield Road, Barnegat, NJ, 08005
MLS#: 22515023
110 Island Road, Toms River, NJ, 08753

$649,000

110 Island Road, Toms River, NJ, 08753
MLS#: 22515022
106 Seagoin Road, Brick, NJ, 08723

$1,032,000

106 Seagoin Road, Brick, NJ, 08723
MLS#: 22515018
35 Brighton Court, Monroe, NJ, 08831

$625,000

35 Brighton Court, Monroe, NJ, 08831
MLS#: 22515019
90 Oak Lane, Eatontown, NJ, 07724

$549,900

90 Oak Lane, Eatontown, NJ, 07724
MLS#: 22515020
1909 Hamilton Boulevard, South Plainfield, NJ, 07080

$697,000

1909 Hamilton Boulevard, South Plainfield, NJ, 07080
MLS#: 2513719R
35 Brighton Court, Monroe, NJ, 08831

$625,000

35 Brighton Court, Monroe, NJ, 08831
MLS#: 2513630R
48 Markham Place, Staten Island, NY, 10314

$789,000

48 Markham Place, Staten Island, NY, 10314
MLS#: 2502909
203 Conifer Crest Way, Eatontown, NJ, 07724

$895,000

203 Conifer Crest Way, Eatontown, NJ, 07724
MLS#: 22515015
54 Wall Street, West Long Branch, NJ, 07764

$599,000

54 Wall Street, West Long Branch, NJ, 07764
MLS#: 22515012
21 Windswept Lane, Freehold, NJ, 07728

$1,199,999

21 Windswept Lane, Freehold, NJ, 07728
MLS#: 22514996
78 Cookman Avenue, Ocean Grove, NJ, 07756

$1,399,000

78 Cookman Avenue, Ocean Grove, NJ, 07756
MLS#: 22515010
1031 Tarragon Court, Morganville, NJ, 07751

$560,000

1031 Tarragon Court, Morganville, NJ, 07751
MLS#: 22514989
64 Sage Street, Holmdel, NJ, 07733

$1,595,000

64 Sage Street, Holmdel, NJ, 07733
MLS#: 22515005
119 Darien Road, Howell, NJ, 07731

$849,900

119 Darien Road, Howell, NJ, 07731
MLS#: 22514975
6 Fred Jahn Drive, Freehold, NJ, 07728

$999,999

6 Fred Jahn Drive, Freehold, NJ, 07728
MLS#: 22514992
168 Stratford Place, Lakewood, NJ, 08701

$389,000

168 Stratford Place, Lakewood, NJ, 08701
MLS#: 22514947
412 Third Avenue, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$699,000

412 Third Avenue, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 22514897
18 Sheridan Avenue 3, Seaside Heights, NJ, 08751

$789,900

18 Sheridan Avenue 3, Seaside Heights, NJ, 08751
MLS#: 22514867
184 Pulaski Boulevard, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$349,000

184 Pulaski Boulevard, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 22515004
21 Wickatunk Road, Manalapan, NJ, 07726

$799,000

21 Wickatunk Road, Manalapan, NJ, 07726
MLS#: 22515009
109 Oneida Lake Drive, Little Egg Harbor, NJ, 08087

$390,000

109 Oneida Lake Drive, Little Egg Harbor, NJ, 08087
MLS#: 22514827
707 Cedar Point Court, Toms River, NJ, 08753

$869,999

707 Cedar Point Court, Toms River, NJ, 08753
MLS#: 22514849
97D Aberdeen Road, Matawan, NJ, 07747

$939,000

97D Aberdeen Road, Matawan, NJ, 07747
MLS#: 22515011
25 Glenview Road, North Caldwell, NJ, 07006

$1,150,000

25 Glenview Road, North Caldwell, NJ, 07006
MLS#: 22515013
341 Chapel Hill Road, Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 07716

$1,099,999

341 Chapel Hill Road, Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 07716
MLS#: 22515002
2090 Lamplighter Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08753

$309,900

2090 Lamplighter Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08753
MLS#: 22514832
159 Harwich Street, Browns Mills, NJ, 08015

$420,000

159 Harwich Street, Browns Mills, NJ, 08015
MLS#: 22514932
(718) 987-7900